Skip to content
Guide · 4 min read

AI Receptionist vs Answering Service vs Hiring a Receptionist

An honest comparison for UK trades: a voice assistant (AI receptionist), a call answering service or hiring someone. What each does, costs and suits.

By Dennis Akinsete ·

If you’re missing calls, there are three realistic ways to fix it: hire someone, use a call answering service staffed by people, or use a voice assistant trained on your business. Each one solves a different problem. Here’s a plain comparison so you can pick the right one for how your business actually works.

Option 1: Hire a receptionist

What you get: a person who knows your business inside out, can deal with tricky customers and can handle admin between calls.

What to weigh up:

  • A salary, plus employer’s National Insurance, pension and holiday cover
  • One person takes one call at a time
  • Office hours only, unless you pay for more
  • Lunch, holidays and sick days leave gaps
  • Recruiting and training take time, and they start again if the person leaves

Best for: busy firms with a steady stream of calls all day and enough office work to fill a full role.

Option 2: A call answering service (people)

What you get: trained staff at a call centre who answer in your business name when you can’t.

What to weigh up:

  • Usually cheaper than hiring, often charged per call or per minute
  • The person answering looks after many businesses, so they rely on a script and won’t know your work in depth
  • Many take a message rather than booking, so you still ring people back
  • Evening and weekend cover may cost extra

Best for: businesses that mainly need a polite message-taker, or where every caller needs a human conversation.

Option 3: A voice assistant trained on your business (an AI receptionist)

What you get: a natural-sounding voice that answers every call in your business name, trained on your services, prices, area and hours. It takes the details and books the job straight into your diary.

What to weigh up:

  • Answers every call at once, day and night, including weekends and bank holidays
  • Books jobs and sends the confirmation text, not just a message
  • Gives the same, consistent answers every time
  • Passes unusual or urgent calls straight to you
  • Needs a proper set-up so it knows your business, which a good provider does with you

Best for: trades and service businesses that are out on jobs, get calls at all hours and want those calls turned into bookings without ringing back.

Side by side

Hire a receptionistAnswering serviceVoice assistant
HoursOffice hoursDepends on planDay and night
Calls at onceOneSeveralAll of them
Knows your businessYes, once trainedPartly, from a scriptYes, trained on it
Books jobsYesOften only takes messagesYes, into your diary
Holidays and sick daysGapsCoveredCovered
Typical costHighestPer call or minuteMonthly plan

The question that decides it

Ask yourself what your callers need when they ring.

If most callers just need reassurance that someone will call back, a message-taking service may be enough.

If most callers are new customers who want the job booked, especially urgent work like a leak, a lockout or a boiler that’s packed up, then a message isn’t enough. They’ll ring the next name on Google. What they need is a time in your diary, there and then.

That’s why a lot of tradespeople find that taking messages doesn’t fix the real problem. They still spend their evenings ringing people back.

Can you mix them?

Yes. Plenty of businesses answer their own phone when they can and let a service cover the rest: when they’re on a job, after a few rings, in the evening and at weekends. You keep your own number either way.

Where Leadplug fits

Leadplug is the third option. A voice assistant trained on your business answers every call, takes the details and books the job into your diary, and tricky calls come straight to you. It can also reply to website and social media enquiries, follow up quotes and ask happy customers for a review. You keep your own number, you can be live within a week, and it’s UK GDPR compliant.

To hear how it would sound for your business, book a free 20-minute call. You’ll get a straight answer on whether it’s the right fit, or whether one of the other options would suit you better.

More reading: how a virtual receptionist works and what it costs in the UK.

Want every call answered, every enquiry followed up and every job booked, without doing it yourself?

Book a call

More straight answers

Stay on the job.
We'll fill the diary.

Book a free 20-minute call. You'll hear it answer and book for your own business, get a straight answer on whether it fits, and no hard sell.

Book a free call

Don't take my word for it. Ring 07488 898304 now: it's the same receptionist your customers would get.

Booked.